Nomination Clarifications Post #1
Apr. 7th, 2024 10:49 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
![[community profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/community.png)
Nominations continue! You can nominate fandoms and relationships here. Nominations close on April 11 at 11:59 PM UTC (7:59 PM EDT).
As a general reminder, please disambiguate nominated relationships - it makes it easier to approve on our end, and makes it more likely for us to catch nominations that wander outside their intended fandom.
Also, please note that a fandom cannot be requested by itself, without a relationship. There are a few nominated fandoms that we have not yet approved because there are no relationships nominated under them.
We have a few specific queries:
Fullmetal Alchemist - All Media Types
Roy Mustang & Wrath | King Bradley (Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood)
The disambiguation for this relationship states it is for Brotherhood, but it is nominated under All Media Types. There is also a "Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood & Manga" fandom in the tagset. Would you like to move this nomination to the Brotherhood & Manga fandom, or keep it under All Media Types?
If you do not reply/change the nomination, we will keep this under All Media Types and change the disambiguation to match.
仮面ライダーギーツ | Kamen Rider Geats:
Azuma Michinaga (KR Geats) & Kadoya Tsukasa (KR DcD)
Azuma Michinaga (KR Geats) & Kaitou Daiki (KR DcD)
Do the characters with the KR DcD disambiguation (Kadoya Tsukasa and Kaitou Daiki) meaningfully appear in Kamen Rider Geats? If not, please move these nominations to "Crossover Fandom."
If you do not reply/change the nomination, we will move these nominations to Crossover Fandom.
Love Live! School Idol Project:
Sakurakouji Kinako/Shibuya Kanon
Shibuya Kanon/Tang Keke
Takasaki Yuu/Uehara Ayumu
These relationships seem to draw from different, standalone entries in the Love Live! franchise rather than their currently nominated fandom. We would prefer to separate these into their distinct fandoms. However, if you want to keep these in the (fandom-accepted?) general franchise tag, we can keep them as is and note this for the future.
If you do not reply/change the nomination, we will approve these nominations in their current state.
Notes on approved nominations:
わが青春のアルカディア | Waga Seishun no Arcadia | Arcadia of My Youth (1982):
Harlock/Maya
The disambiguation for this relationship was for a different fandom. However, since the characters do seem to appear in this canon, we changed the disambiguation to reflect the nominated fandom.
Rockman X | Mega Man X:
Axl/X/Zero
Layer/Zero
The disambiguations for these relationships seem to be for the more general series. We changed the disambiguations to reflect the specific canon.
As a general reminder, please disambiguate nominated relationships - it makes it easier to approve on our end, and makes it more likely for us to catch nominations that wander outside their intended fandom.
Also, please note that a fandom cannot be requested by itself, without a relationship. There are a few nominated fandoms that we have not yet approved because there are no relationships nominated under them.
We have a few specific queries:
Fullmetal Alchemist - All Media Types
The disambiguation for this relationship states it is for Brotherhood, but it is nominated under All Media Types. There is also a "Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood & Manga" fandom in the tagset. Would you like to move this nomination to the Brotherhood & Manga fandom, or keep it under All Media Types?
If you do not reply/change the nomination, we will keep this under All Media Types and change the disambiguation to match.
Do the characters with the KR DcD disambiguation (Kadoya Tsukasa and Kaitou Daiki) meaningfully appear in Kamen Rider Geats? If not, please move these nominations to "Crossover Fandom."
If you do not reply/change the nomination, we will move these nominations to Crossover Fandom.
These relationships seem to draw from different, standalone entries in the Love Live! franchise rather than their currently nominated fandom. We would prefer to separate these into their distinct fandoms. However, if you want to keep these in the (fandom-accepted?) general franchise tag, we can keep them as is and note this for the future.
If you do not reply/change the nomination, we will approve these nominations in their current state.
Notes on approved nominations:
わが青春のアルカディア | Waga Seishun no Arcadia | Arcadia of My Youth (1982):
The disambiguation for this relationship was for a different fandom. However, since the characters do seem to appear in this canon, we changed the disambiguation to reflect the nominated fandom.
Rockman X | Mega Man X:
The disambiguations for these relationships seem to be for the more general series. We changed the disambiguations to reflect the specific canon.
no subject
Date: 2024-04-08 03:40 pm (UTC)Hm. I swear I read it somewhere that crossover relationships should be under either fandom, I probably fucked up and misread something. Sorry about that. They are indeed crossover rels.
I cannot move them as I have all my slots taken and already accepted, though.
no subject
Date: 2024-04-09 04:03 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2024-04-09 10:17 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2024-04-10 02:38 pm (UTC)