Nominations Clarifications Post #1
Apr. 5th, 2022 11:15 pm![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
Nominations continue! As a general reminder, please disambiguate nominations – it makes approving nominations easier, and we are more likely to notice if a nomination unintentionally synned to something else (ex. because you nominated a specific version that AO3 synns to the general canon). Let us know if this already happened, or if you want to nominate specifics under the general canon!
We also have a few specific inquiries:
Incorrect formatting
If you’ve nominated in the following fandoms, please check that your nominations are in the correct format:
Loveless (Anime & Manga)
Fullmetal Alchemist - All Media Types - Edward Elric (FMA AMT)/Envy (FMA 2003) - We interpreted this as “Any version of Edward Elric shipped with only the 2003 version of Envy.” Is this what the nominator intended?
If so, we have a follow-up question: Are you ok with the tag appearing in FMA - All Media Types only? We can, for instance, move it to FMA - 2003, or duplicate it there. Crossover Fandom could also be a potential location.
Persona 5 - Akechi Goro/Yoshizawa Sumire (Persona 5 Royal Video Game) - We approved this in Persona 5, but should we separate this out to Persona 5 Royal? As far as we can tell, Yoshizawa Sumire doesn’t exist in base Persona 5, so there shouldn’t be overlap with the original game, but we can move it to a Royal-specific tag.
Story of Seasons: Pioneers of Olive Town (Video Game) -
Karina/Lara (SoS: PoOT) -
Did you mean Laura instead of Lara?
Eiji (Male Player Character)/Iori (SoS: PoOT)
Yuka (Female Player Character)/Iori (SoS: PoOT)
Yuka (Female Player Character)/Iori/Matsuyuki (SoS: PoOT)
Yuka (Female Player Character)/Linh (SoS: PoOT)
It seems that Eiji and Yuka are canon names for the Player Characters (at least in Japanese?). We can approve these tags with just Eiji and Yuka, unless you want Male/Female Player Character without specified names?
We also have a few specific inquiries:
If you’ve nominated in the following fandoms, please check that your nominations are in the correct format:
If so, we have a follow-up question: Are you ok with the tag appearing in FMA - All Media Types only? We can, for instance, move it to FMA - 2003, or duplicate it there. Crossover Fandom could also be a potential location.
Did you mean Laura instead of Lara?
It seems that Eiji and Yuka are canon names for the Player Characters (at least in Japanese?). We can approve these tags with just Eiji and Yuka, unless you want Male/Female Player Character without specified names?